Blog
Why sales went up but profit didn't
- Compare each cost as a percent of sales, year over year.
- Lost margin usually hides in pricing, labor, or cost of goods.
- Fix the line that moved, then watch it monthly.
You had your best sales year ever. You worked more hours than ever. And somehow there's no more money in the bank than there was two years ago.
It's one of the most common things owners run into. When sales grow and profit doesn't, something grew with the sales and ate the difference. The job is to find it.
Start by pulling your P&L for this year and the same period last year. Put them side by side. Dollars won't tell you much, because everything goes up when sales go up. So for every major line, divide it by total sales. Now you're comparing percentages. If cost of goods was 30% of sales last year and it's 36% this year, you just found six points of margin.
There are three places it usually hides.
The first is pricing. Your costs went up over the last two years: supplies, rent, insurance, wages. If your prices didn't move with them, every sale now earns you less than it used to. Owners tend to hold prices because they're afraid of losing customers, and they lose margin instead without noticing.
The second is labor. Growth usually means hiring, and new people take time to get productive. Overtime creeps in. Schedules get built around busy days and never trimmed back for slow ones. If labor as a percentage of sales went up, that's where to look.
The third is cost of goods. Vendors raise prices a little at a time, waste goes up when you're busy, and nobody's watching portions or materials as closely as they did when it was just you. A few points here on a large sales number is a lot of money.
Once you know which line moved, you know what to fix. Raise prices on the items or services that have fallen behind your costs. Build the schedule around real sales by day. Rebid your biggest vendors and check your waste. Then watch that same percentage every month so it doesn't drift again.
This matters beyond your own paycheck, too. When a buyer sees sales growing and profit flat, they read it as a business that gets harder as it gets bigger, and they pay less for it.